Fact check: Governor denies diverting transportation funds, budget says otherwise

Governor-elect Ned Lamont reacts when speaking to supporters in Hartford, Conn., Wednesday, Nov. 7, 2018. Lamont won election Wednesday as Connecticut’s governor, keeping the office in Democratic hands in part by promising to be a “firewall” against the policies of President Donald Trump. (AP Photo/Jessica Hill

During his hour-long interview with WTIC 1080, Gov. Ned Lamont fielded questions from callers, one of whom questioned why the state diverted $170 million in vehicle sales tax from the Special Transportation Fund.

The governor denied that funds had been diverted, labeling it a “myth.”

“That’s a myth that gets perpetuated day in and day out and there’s just no truth to it,” the governor said. “What people are referring to in the car tax and starting in 2017, that car tax used to go into the general fund, we started putting it in the transportation fund… that is still happening, there’s no diversion taking place, so you can put that to rest.”

Similarly, in a press conference at the Capitol, House Speaker Joe Aresimowicz, D-Berlin, said he was tired of hearing that the state had diverted funds away from the STF and that he wanted to address “honesty” in the public.

“It has to stop, all these accusations of past acts by the legislature and what we’re going to do moving forward,” Aresimowicz said. “They talked about us misappropriating the STF, even this year, we all know that didn’t happen. It didn’t happen. We changed the structure, but we never went in and took the money out.”

Although Aresimowicz is correct that the legislature did not take funds out of the STF this year – the STF is protected with a constitutional lock box – the legislature and governor did divert $171.6 million in vehicle sales tax revenue away from transportation fund and into the General Fund.

It’s quite literally in the budget.

Fiscal Analysis for 2020/2021 budget

The bi-partisan budget passed in 2017 sought to bolster the transportation fund at a time when Gov. Dannel Malloy was calling for numerous tolls on Connecticut highways to pay for his extended infrastructure plan called “Let’s Go CT.” 

According to that budget signed into law, sales tax revenue from vehicle purchases would be transferred from the General Fund into the STF, ramping up from 8 percent of vehicle sales tax revenue in 2017 to 100 percent by 2024.

Beginning in 2020, the vehicle sales tax transfer was supposed to be 33 percent of revenue, growing to 56 percent by 2021.

When Lamont released his first budget proposal in February of 2019, however, he sought to freeze the transfer amount at 8 percent, which would have short-changed the STF by $1.19 billion.

Because the sales tax revenue would not already be in the STF, it was not protected by the lock box. The proposal was also not considered a “raid” or a “sweep” of the STF, which was no longer possible under the lock box, but rather a “diversion.”

The legislature, in their drafting of a budget, adjusted the governor’s withholding of vehicle sales tax revenue from the STF. Instead of freezing it at 8 percent indefinitely, the legislature decreased the amount of the transfer in 2020 from 33 percent to 17 percent and in 2021 from 56 percent to 25 percent.

That resulted in $171 million less into the transportation fund over 2020 and 2021.

Budget language showing the reduction in vehicle sales tax revenue to go to the STF

Since Connecticut has a biannual budget, years 2022 through 2024 of vehicle sales tax transfers were left untouched. Democrats likely recognized the optics of the diverting money away from the STF when leadership was claiming tolls were needed to fund transportation.

But that doesn’t mean the same thing can’t be done in the next budget-writing session. 

Because vehicle sales tax revenue is deposited first into the General Fund and then transferred to the Special Transportation Fund, leadership and the governor can claim they are still putting money into transportation – just not as much as the 2017 budget had allocated – and they can say that all the vehicle sales tax revenue will eventually be put into the STF, provided there are no future budget changes.

But they can’t deny that $171 million of vehicle sales tax revenue that was supposed to go into the STF in 2020 and 2021 under previous law was diverted to the General Fund in the latest budget.

And at least one Democratic senator said he wasn’t pleased with the revenue diversion.

Speaking at the Wilton Library on June 17, Sen. Will Haskell, D-Wilton, answered the exact same question addressed to Lamont during his radio interview — why the legislature diverted part of the vehicle sales revenue — but gave a much different answer.

“It was certainly not something I was pleased about in the budget as an advocate for tolls and an advocate for greater transportation funding,” Haskell said. “In the future, I do not think we should be diverting money that’s supposed to go into the transportation fund.”

Meghan Portfolio contributed to this article

Climate modeling shows regional gas tax would have no effect on climate change

The Transportation and Climate Initiative is pushing for a regional cap and trade system on gasoline distributors to fight climate change, invest in mass transit and fight for climate justice, but scientific modeling suggests the program would have no impact on global temperatures. Up to thirteen states on the eastern ...

Read More

Connecticut’s loss of taxpayers in 2017, by the numbers

Connecticut saw a net loss of 9,869 income tax filers between 2017 and 2018, constituting a loss of adjusted gross income totaling $1.1 billion, according to the Internal Revenue Service. The breakdown of earnings relative to population loss show that although Connecticut’s highest earners were not the largest group of ...

Read More

  1. Pete Ross

    January 16, 2020 2:13 pm

    I thank the Yankee Institute for making this issue clear. This is a perfect example of how Democrat politicians word smith the truth to fit their agenda. This is typical of how the citizens of Connecticut have been lied to over the years which resulted in the dismal financial situation the state is currently in. I can only hope these manipulative politicians are voted out of office and replaced with citizens that represent the will of the people – which is “no more taxes” and “reduce the size of government”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *