Office of the Governor did not have supporting figures for truck-only toll numbers, according to FOI Commission hearing

During an October 29 hearing before the Freedom of Information Commission, an attorney representing the Office of the Governor said the department was not in possession of specific data supporting the administration’s revenue claims for truck-only tolls.

Former Sen. Len Suzio, R-Meriden, who served on the Transportation Committee, filed a Freedom of Information request shortly after the Lamont administration presented revenue estimates for truck-only tolls to the public in December 2019.

The Governor’s Office and the Department of Transportation estimated an average toll of $8 per truck on bridges would bring in $187.1 million per year and would be used to finance transportation projects with the help of federal infrastructure loans.

Although the administration published revenue estimates for tolling trucks on Connecticut bridges, Suzio sought the underlying data to support those figures. 

Suzio filed his FOI request in December 2019 and did not receive the data until February 2020, after he had filed a complaint. The data he received did not account for eight dollar truck tolls but rather a wide array of different toll rates.

“There was never any supporting schedule that matched [eight dollar tolls],” Suzio said during the hearing. “Ironically, there were supporting schedules that matched five dollars and seven dollars and other rates but there was never anything to match that.”

“No responsible leader would use financial projections without having the data to support the numbers,” Suzio said in an October 30 press release. “Today I heard in sworn testimony from the Governor’s staff that they do not have the documentation to support the claims and projections provided by Governor Lamont to the media and the public.”

Gov. Lamont and Democrat leaders announce support for truck-only tolls at Governor’s Mansion in November 2019

But just because the Office of the Governor did not have the responsive numbers does not mean they don’t exist within another department, according to attorney representing the Office of the Governor, Philip Miller.

During the hearing before the Freedom of Information Commission, Miller said that he provided Suzio with all the documents possessed by the Office of the Governor, but the supporting figures and calculations may be in the possession of the Department of Transportation or the Office of Policy and Management. 

Suzio had filed an FOI request with DOT but did not file a complaint against the department.

“There’s meetings with OPM, there’s meetings with DOT, they’re briefing [Gov. Lamont], providing the information, but I don’t know that they go in with all the Excel spreadsheets,” Miller said. “He’s kind of getting the executive summary and then whatever questions he has I’m sure get answered.” 

“We provided everything we had,” Miller said.

Emails provided to Suzio show the Governor’s Office was in contact with DOT and OPM regarding the truck tolls and calculating the underlying revenue numbers. 

In an email chain starting on December 2, 2019 OPM Secretary Melissa McCaw asked DOT to “provide the blended rates for the $8.00 average” with a possible $20 charge for the Gold Star Memorial Bridge.

Chief of Policy and Planning for DOT Thomas J. Maziarz responded they had received gross revenue estimates from the consultant and were working on getting the net revenue estimate the following day.

“The initial results are promising,” Maziarz wrote. “We believe that when we make all the needed adjustments, the net annual revenue will increase from the previous $180 million to at least $190 million.” 

Lamont and fellow Democrats put the tolls issue to rest in late 2019 after neither legislative chamber could muster the will to vote on the measure.

Thus far, statements from both Lamont and out-going Speaker of the House Joe Aresimowicz, D-Berlin, indicate there is little political interest in pursuing the matter further, but some Senate Democrats have continued to push the issue during the 2020 campaign season.

Suzio lost his bid to win back his seat from Mary Dougherty Abrams, D-Meriden.

Marc E. Fitch

Marc E. Fitch

Marc E. Fitch is the author of several books and novels including Shmexperts: How Power Politics and Ideology are Disguised as Science and Paranormal Nation: Why America Needs Ghosts, UFOs and Bigfoot. Marc was a 2014 Robert Novak Journalism Fellow and his work has appeared in The Federalist, American Thinker, The Skeptical Inquirer, World Net Daily and Real Clear Policy. Marc has a Master of Fine Arts degree from Western Connecticut State University. Marc can be reached at Marc@YankeeInstitute.org

1 Comment

  1. Avatar len SUZIO
    November 13, 2020 @ 4:28 pm

    This is a good article, but it gives the impression that the only supporting data (for the Governor’s “Trucks Only Tolls” projections) not provided to me was the $8 toll rate. The truth is I had asked for details supporting various projected costs and spending items in the Governor’s projections and not a single document provided to me by the governor’s office matched the figures he was touting publicly!

    If the governor were a responsible leader he would have demanded the supporting data and the underlying assumptions and he would have scrutinized that supporting data and questioned the assumptions. This information is what I wanted to review to determine how reasonable his projections were. But his office says it doesn’t have the data which suggests he never saw it (because if he had asked for the information it would have been in the possession of his office). This is another example of an irresponsible and incompetent governor. Connecticut needs better leaders than this.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *